#AuditFailure

2026-01-06

Piramal Finance and the Rating Ruse: How India’s Credit Rating Agencies Manufacture Trust to Enable Systemic Expropriation
onceinabluemoon2021.in/2026/01
A research-driven critique of credit ratings as instruments of trust manufacture, regulatory capture, and financial extraction—mapped through the DHFL–Piramal finance continuum.
, ,a, , , , ,

Under India’s captured financial regime during BJP–NDA rule (2014–2025), credit rating agencies—dominated by the CRISIL-ICRA-CARE triopoly—have shifted from risk sentinels to enablers of crony expropriation, sustaining a cycle of manufactured trust, retail entrapment, delayed collapse, and oligarchic consolidation. The Piramal Finance–DHFL case is emblematic: despite whistleblowers, Cobrapost exposés, and KPMG audits revealing ₹29,000–34,000 crore in promoter diversion, investment-grade ratings persisted until DHFL’s 2019 default, enabling reckless borrowing. Post-collapse, Piramal—amid allegations of political shielding and elite proximity—acquired DHFL through a controversial IBC resolution that priced ~₹45,000 crore in suspected fraud recoveries at Re 1, while ~2.5 lakh retail depositors suffered 55–77% haircuts and losses exceeding ₹50,000 crore across NBFC failures. Rapidly rehabilitated via reverse-merger alchemy, Piramal Finance secured fresh AA+/Stable ratings in January 2026, lowering funding costs and restoring legitimacy even as governance risks linger. This pattern—issuer-pays conflicts, oligopolistic convergence, and “too-connected-to-fail” pricing—reveals CRAs as architects of performative credibility that privatizes distressed assets and socializes ruin, demanding structural rupture through de-captured ratings, personal liability, and retail-centred justice.

Client Info

Server: https://mastodon.social
Version: 2025.07
Repository: https://github.com/cyevgeniy/lmst